HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 3810 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 2951-end ed. Hardin A. Aasand
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
3810 Follow my mother. <King Dyes.> 38105.2.327
1736 Stubbs
Stubbs
3810-15] [Stubbs] (1736, p. 39) : <p. 39>“Since the Poet deferred so long the Usurper’s Death, we must own, that he has very naturally effected it, and still added fresh Crimes to those the Murderer had already committed.
“Upon Laertes’s Repentance for contriving the Death of Hamlet , one cannot but feel some Sentiments of Pity for him; but who can see or read the Death of the young Prince without melting into Tears and Compassion? Horatio’s earnest desire to die with the Prince, (p. 365, and Sequel,) thus not to survive his Friend, gives a stronger Idea of his Friendship for Hamlet in the few Lines on that Occasion, than many Actions or Expressions could possibly have done. And Hamlet’s begging him to draw his Breath in this Harsh World a little longer, to clear his Reputation and manifest his Innocence, is very suitable to his virtuous Character, and the honest Regard that all Men should have not to be misrepresented to Posterity; that they may not set a bad Example, when in reality they have set a good one; which is the only Motive that can, in Reason, recommend the Love of Fame and Glory. “ </p. 39>
1870 Miles
Miles
3810 Miles (1870, p. 85): <p. 85>“O the awful irony of that fell interrogative! deadlier, bitterer than steel or bowl! The last lightning of that departing intelligence! With one outstretched arm he plucks their monarch from their midst, drags him to the ground, pinions him between his feet; with the other, forces the ‘potent poison’ down the reluctant throat,—overwhelming, in one tremendous second, the prostrate villain with a thousand deaths.
“The king is ground to dust in that lurid hurricane of passion! mind, soul and body shrivel up in that furnace of wrath! And so it might have been, at almost any moment, since that night on the platform. He was conscious of this latent, immeasurable force; it never yet failed him at need; at the right moment, it was ever sure to come at his call. An avenger so justly confident of his strength, may safely await the hour which retribution is so righteous and complete, that it resembles less a human intervention than a divine dispensation.”</p. 85>
1881 hud3
hud3
3810 Hudson (ed. 1881): “Of course the King dies of the wound,—dies without drinking the poison. Hamlet, instantly seeing the way clear for the avenging stroke, and having a free thrust at Claudius, can hardly be supposed to leave any thing for poison to do.”
1885 macd
macd
3810 MacDonald (ed. 1885): “A grim play on the word Union: ‘follow my mother’. It suggests a terrible meeting below.”
1980 pen2
pen2
3810 King Dyes] Spencer (ed. 1980): “Claudius dies without contrition or forgiveness, unlike Laertes.”
1999 Dessen & Thomson
Dessen & Thomson
3810 Dyes Dessen & Thomson(1999) point out that “typically the action is indicated by the words of the dying figure, eliminating the need to specify who dies . . . “ and, we might add, even for a SD, as in Q2 3810 and 3847.
3810