HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 3432 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 2951-end ed. Hardin A. Aasand
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
3432 A ministring Angell shall my sister be5.1.241
1870 Miles
Miles
3429-38 Miles (1870, 74): <p. 74>“How different this high-bred, graceful lament [3435-8] from the low wailing of Laertes. This choleric stripling, whose heart was in Paris; who cowers before a ‘King of shreds and patches,’ yet bullies an irresponsible and discretionless priest; who had even more than the full fraternal indifference to his sister until she lost her reason and her life; this small Hector must now make a scene over her death body. And such a scene!” </p. 74>
1874 Tyler
Tyler
3429-3433 Tyler (1874, p. 13): <p. 13> “. . . the idol of Hamlet’s heart, the maiden whom he loved with a love greater than that of ‘forty thousand brothers,’ was not singularly depraved. Her disease was the disease of humanity. Indeed it would appear to have been the poet’s intention to represent Ophelia as distinguished, in comparison with others, by a high degree of moral purity. Shakespeare’s general conception of her character, in this respect, is not unsuitably expressed by the words which her brother addresses to the priest, by her grave:— [cites 3429-33].” </p. 13>
1877 Gervinus
Gervinus
3432-3 A . . . howling] Gervinus (1877, p. 580): <p. 580> “Far less can we accept those other views, which returned to the rude legend in ‘Saxo Grammaticus,’ regarding Ophelia as a fallen innocent. It would not have been in accordance with the fine feeling of Shakespeare to have made the brother utter those sublime words over the corpse of such a fallen one, when the preist would fain refuse her ‘sanctified ground’—’A ministering angel shall my sister be, When thou liest howling.’ It would not have been like the poet to say expressly over her grave:—’From her fair and unpolluted flesh May violets spring!’ It would indeed have been a frivolous insult to innocence in the most solemn place and moment.” </p. 580>
3432