HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 2900 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 2023-2950 ed. Frank N. Clary
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
2900 That I am guiltlesse of your fathers death, 29004.5.150
1854 White
White: contra john
2900-03 That . . .eye ] White (1854, pp. 419-420): <p.419> “Johnson says that, ‘It shall as level to your judgement pierce,’ <p.419></p.420> which is the reading of the original, is ‘less intelligible’ than, ‘It shall as level to your judgement ’pear,’ which is the reading the quarto of 1611, and which appears in all the modern editions except Mr. Knight’s. If Johnson had not said so, it would be difficult to believe that he could say so. What can be more intelligible than that a conviction should pierce to the judgement, as level [i.e. as directly, as ‘point blank’] as light does to the eye. This is clear sense and forcible comparison. But use ’pear [appear], and nonsense and confusion ensue. The lines as they stand in the authentic text assert,—‘it [the conviction] shall pierce as level to your judgement as the day does [pierce] to your eye;’ but use ‘’pear,’ or ‘appear,’ and the assertion would be that – ‘it shall appear as level to your judgement as the day does [appear] to your eye.’ But how does, or how can, day appear level to the eye? The absurdity is palpable. In the copies in general use, Johnson is followed and ‘’pear’ is given. The original text should be restored without question.” </p.420>
2900