HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 2464 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 2023-2950 ed. Frank N. Clary
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
2464 {Ger.}<Qu.> O Hamlet speake no more,3.4.88
1752 ANON
ANON: Sophocles S&A
2464 (1752, p. 41-2): <p.41> “This Play is said to resemble the Electra of Sophocles, and it is like it in many Respects. Gertrude and Clytemnestra are Characters nearly allied. Both were Queen, both Adulteresses, and both of them had their Hands imbrued in the Blood of their Lords and Masters. The latter had some Excuse for the bloody Deed, the former none ot all. She was affectionately beloved by a King who had all the Bravery of Mars, join’d with the Beauty of Apollo, and she rewarded him for his Tenderness, by ent’ring into a Conspiracy with a cowardly Ruffian, and depriving him his Life and Crown at the same Time. Clytemnestra was no less guilty, but more open; she acknowledged the Fact and gloried in it. Nay, went so far as to declare, that it was Justice that struck him, not her alone.[GREEK HERE]
“But her Provocations were great. Agamemnon had enticed her Daughter Iphigenia to Aulis, and there sacrificed her on an Altar, to favour the Cause of the Argives. This cruel Treatment incensed her so much that she vow’d Revenge, and the very Night of his Return from Troy, assisted by Egistbus, assassinated him in his own Palace. Honest capricious Ovid, who is always an Advocate for the fair Sex, excuses this Lady upon another Account with his usual Humour. </p.41><p.42> ‘Dum fuit Atrides una contentus, & illa Casta fuit; vitio est improba facta viri. Audierat, laurumque manu, vittasque serentem Pro nata Chryseb non valuisse sua. Audierat Lyrnesi tuos abducta dolores, Bellaque per Turpes longius isse moras. Haec tantum sudierat. Primeida viderat ipfa. Victor erat Praedae Praeda pudenda fuae. Inde Thyestiaden animo Thalamoque recepit, Et male peccantem Tyndatis ultra virum est. De Arte Amandi, Lib.II.” </p.42>
1754 Grey
Grey: Saxo Grammaticus S&A
2464-67 O Hamlet . . . . tin’ct] Grey (1754, p. 298): “See this confirmed by Saxo Grammaticus.
<n.>“Tali convicio laceratam matrem, ad excolendum virtutis habitum revocavit, præsentibus illecebris præferre docuit. Id. ib.” </n.>
Reference is to Saxo and to Meursii.
1819 Jackson
Jackson
2464-67 O Hamlet . . . . tin’ct] Jackson (1819, pp. 354 ): “There is also another passage in this scene which helps to confirm the Queen’s innocence. The stings of conscience have seldom an intermission when they arise from murder; but the passion of love, in a female breast, rarely admits scruples, whether the connection be of an incestuous nature or an act of adultery, so long as the object with whom she maintains a criminal intercourse pays that attention which first actuated her to violate propriety. Now, this being the case with the Queen, who, in the gratification of sensuality, has never looked into her soul to seek the blush of shame, her conscience remains without a sting: nor does she consider herself guilty, until roused by the hideous picture drawn by Hamlet of her incestuous intercourse; and then only does she feel the enormity of that offence, which induces her thus to testify her contrition,—‘O Hamlet . . . tinct.’”
See [1.5.42 (729)] and [3.4.29-30 (2410-1)], [3.4.31-39 (2412-22)].
1882 Bowman
Bowman
2464-5 Bowman (1882 in Thom 1883, p. 1): “That the Queen is no hardened sinner, is evident from the readiness with which she acknowledges her real fault, and the horror with which she shrinks from the wretched creature drawn by Hamlet’s excited imagination, and held up as a fac-simile of herself, who was ’her husband’s brother’s wife.’ .”
1885 macd
macd
2464 MacDonald (ed. 1885): “She gives way at last.”
2464