HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 2079 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 2023-2950 ed. Frank N. Clary
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
2079 Our wills and fates doe so contrary runne,3.2.211
1854 del2
del2
2079 contrary] Delius (ed. 1854): “contráry ist Sh.’s Betonung.” [contráry is Shakespeare’s emphasis.]
1857 fieb
fieb
2079 contrary] Fiebig (ed. 1857): “contráry] Anciently, this word, as it appears by the poets, was most commonly pronounced by the learned, as it is now by the vulgar, with the acccent on the second syllable; but nothing can be now more firmly established than the accent on the first syllable, and the other pronunciation must be scrupulously avoided.”
Despite advocating for a first-syllable accent, Fiebig’s text includes the accent over the second syllable. Compare dyce1.
1869 tsch
tsch
2079 Tschischwitz (ed. 1869): “Der Inhalt des Gedankens our wills - overthrown bestätigt sich durch Hamlets eignes Schicksal in der dritten und vierten Scene desselben Actes.” [The content of the thought our wills—overthrown is confirmed by Hamlet’s own fate in the third and fourth scenes of the same act.]
1870 Abbott
Abbott: Jonson analogue; Ellis (quoting Child for Chaucer analogue)
2079 contrary] Abbott (1870, §490): ‘Many words, such as ‘edict,’ ‘outrage,’ ‘contract,’ &c., are accented in a varying manner. The key to this inconsistency is, perhaps, to be found in Ben Jonson’s remark that all disyllabic nouns, if they be simple, are accented on the first. Hence ‘edict’ and ‘outrage’ would generally be accented on the first, but, when they were regarded as derived from verbs, they would be accented on the second. And so, perhaps, when ‘exile’ is regarded as a person, and therefore a ‘simple’ noun, the accent is on the first, but when as ‘the state of being exiled,’ it is on the last. But naturally, where the difference is so slight, much variety may be expected. Ben Jonson adds that ‘all verbs coming from the Latin, either of the supine or otherwise, hold the accent as it is found in the first person present of those Latin verbs; as from celebre, celebrate.’ Without entering into the details of this rule, it seems probable that ‘edict,’ ‘precept,’ betray Latin influence. The same fluctuation between the English and French accent is found in Chaucer (Prof. Child, quoted by Ellis, E. E. Pronunc. i. 369), who uses ‘bataille,’ C. T. 990, and ‘batail,’ ib. 2099: ‘Fortune,’ ib. 917, and ‘fortune,’ ib. 927; ‘daunger,’ and ‘daunger. Contrary (Latin). – ‘Our wills / and fates / do so / contra / ry run.’ Ham. Ham. [3.2.211 (2079)].”
1872 del4
del4 ≈ del2
1877 v1877
v1877: Abbott
2079 contrary] Furness (ed. 1877): “For words in which the accent is nearer the end than with us, see Abbott, §490.”
1878 rlf1
rlf1: Schmidt (KJ, WT, Rom. //s)
2079 contrary] Rolfe (ed. 1878): “The accent on the penult, as in ‘Mary, Mary, quite contrary,’ etc. Cf. KJ [4.2.198 (1923)]. Schmidt adds WT [5.1.45 (2778)]: ‘My lord should to the heavens be contrary;’ but there it seems to have the other accent, as in Rom. [3.2.64 (1714)]: ‘What storm is this that blows so contrary?’ etc.”
1891 dtn
dtn: v1877 (Abbott)
2079 contrary] Deighton (ed. 1912): “in such opposite directions to each other ; for instances of words in which the accent is nearer the end than with us, see Abb. § 490.”
1903 rlf3
rlf3 ≈ rlf1 minus WT //, Schmidt attribution + magenta underlined
2079 contrary] rolfe (ed.1903): “The accent on the penult, as in ‘Mary, Mary, quite contrary,’ etc. Cf. [4.2.198 (1923)] and Tim. [4.3.144 (1759)]. For the other accent cf. Rom. [3.2.64 (1714)]: ‘What storm is this that blows so contrary?’ etc.”
1939 kit2
kit2 ≈ v1877
2079 contrary] Kittredge (ed. 1939): “contráry] Note the accent.”
1980 pen2
pen2
2079 Our wills and fates] Spencer (ed. 1980): “what we want to happen and what is fated to happen to us.”
pen2
2079 contrary] Spencer (ed. 1980): “in contrary directions.”
1988 bev2
bev2 ≈ pen2 + magenta underlined
2079 Bevington (ed. 1988): “what we want and what we get go so contrarily.”
2079