HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 1295-7 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 1018-2022 ed. Eric Rasmussen
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
1295 < Ham. Why then ’tis none to you; for there is nothing> 2.2.250
1296 <either good or bad, but thinking makes it so: to me it is>
1297 <a prison.>
1885 macd
macd
1296 but thinking makes it so] MacDonald (ed. 1885): “ ‘but is thinking that makes it so:’”
1889 Tomlinson
Tomlinson
1295-7 Why...prison]Tomlinson (1889, p. 7): “. . . [T]he charge of scepticism is not warranted by the sentiment quoted by Schlegel, for it is uttered not with reference to the morally good or bad, but to the physical, or outward good or bad. Hamlet says that Denmark is a prison; Rosencranz does not think so; then comes the natural rejoinder, ‘Why then ’tis none to you; for there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so. To me it is a prison’.”
1934a cam3
1295-6 Why...so] Wilson (ed. 1934): “A commonplace of the age; cf. Spenser, F.Q. vi. ix. 30 ‘It is the mind that maketh good or ill’; Euphues (Bond, I. 193) ‘it is ye disposition of the thought yt altereth ye nature of ye thing. The Sun shineth vppon the dungehill and is not corrupted’ ( the juxtapostion of the two sentiments is interesting,); Oth. [1.3.320. (673)] ‘’tis in ourselves that we are thus or thus,’ etc.”
1982 ard2
ard2 = ard1
1295-6 Why...so] Jenkins (ed. 1982): "This common reflection was probably given currency by Montaigne’s essay. ’That the taste of goods or evils doth greatly depend on the opinion we have of them’ (I. 40). See it also in Spenser, FQ, VI. ix. 30, ’It is the mind, that maketh good or ill, That maketh wretch or happy’ ; Donne, The Progress of the Soul, ll. 518-20 ; Robt. Johnson, Essays (1601, BIv), ’All worldly happiness hath his being only by opinion’ ; etc. See also Tilley M 254. It is clear from the contexts that ’good’ and ’bad’ here are not a matter of ethics : the inference that Hamlet maintains that there are no ethical absolutes (Levin, The Question of Hamlet, p. 75) is false."
1295 1296 1297