HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 838 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 0-1017 ed. Bernice W. Kliman
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
838 Booth. My Lord we will not.1.5.145
2000 Kliman
Kliman
538-78 Kliman (2000): The men, first, promise without repeating Hamlet’s words. Hamlet asks them to swear it. Their response is to swear on their faith, first Horatio, then Marcellus. Hamlet then asks them to swear on his sword. They exhibit some reluctance about that: Marcellus says they have already sworn. Then follows the potentially comic or irreverent scene with the ghost seconding Hamlet’s request. Horatio asks Hamlet to propose the oath. Hamlet does: “Never to speak of this that you have seen.” This wording is the same as [or close to] that of 837. Presumably they are ready to do this, but the Ghost’s iteration of Hamlet’s swear, and their removal either closer to or away from the Ghost, delays it, and Hamlet repeats the oath, changing it somewhat from what you have seen to what you have heard. Before, they had merely seen the Ghost; now they have heard it also—at least Hamlet’s revisal suggests that. Of course a production can still decide that they have not heard. Now we do not hear them say that they swear, using the words that Horatio had asked for. But after another remove, and Horatio’s reaction, Hamlet no longer asks them to speak the words, or swear, so presumably they have silently sworn on the sword, by touching it or kissing it. Or perhaps Hamlet has given up on hearing the exact words said on the sword.
Ed. note: See de Grazia, 2007, in 845 CN.
838 845