HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 688 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 0-1017 ed. Bernice W. Kliman
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
688 Ham. Alas poore Ghost.1.5.4
1855 Wade
Wade
688-92 Wade (1855, p. 6):“ . . . the spirit all along doubts of the efficacy of its own earthy readvent; it repudiates that pity which is so eagerly administered by Hamlet; and emphatically intimates to him that it comes to be heard, not to be pitied, and not to be heard only, but to be avenged when heard—a very supererogatory intimation to any but the most undecided of human agents!— [quotes 688-92].”
Ed. note:continuing a pt he starts in 714-17, which see.
1875 Marshall
Marshall
688-90 Marshall (1875, p. 20): “The rapt attention of Hamlet—the expression of pity, ‘Alas! poor ghost,’ instantly checked by the sad rebuke, ‘Pity me not, but . . . unfold;’ the splendid resonance of every line which the ghost utters; the very apprehension which his first words excite, lest he should be recalled to the ‘sulphurous and tormenting flames’ before he has completed the solemn charge of vengeance—all these circumstances and masterly touches of the poet combine together to produce such a vivid impression of the supernatural, as no effort of the painter or the mechanist could ever hope to accomplish.”
1904 Bradley
Bradley
688 Alas poore Ghost] Bradley (1904, rpt. 2007, p. 109, n.16) finds “something characteristic. . . in the coincidence of . . . ’Alas poor Yorick’ [3372].”
1908 Stewart
Stewart
688 ghost] Stewart (1906, p. 38): Sh. introduces 14 ghosts in all. in Ham., R3, JC, and Mac.
688 3372