HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 146 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 0-1017 ed. Bernice W. Kliman
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
146 Bar. It was about to speake when the cock crewe.1.1.147
1736 Stubbs
Stubbs
146 the cock crewe] Stubbs (1736, p. 12) “The Speeches in consequence of this Observation [by Bernardo] are truly beautiful, and are properly Marks of a great Genius; as also are these Lines which describe the Morning, are in the true Spirit of Poetry.” I find it hard to figure out what to do with such comments. These are appreciations but without any observations or details that support the judgment. Still, it should be recorded simply as an instance of this kind of “criticism,” in the tradition of pointing out the beauties. Here}s the rest: “And as to [Sh.’s] complying with the vulgar Notions of Spirits amongst the English atthat Time, so far fom being low, it adds a Grace and a Naïveté to the whole Passagem which one can much easier be sensible of than know how to make others so.”
1754 Grey
Grey
146 the cock crewe] Grey (1754, 2:283) notes: “The first crowing of the cock is described by Spenser in the following manner, [F.Q. 5.6.27]. ‘What time the native bell-man of the night,This bird, that warned Peter of his fate, First rings his silver bell to each sleepy wight,That should their minds up to devotion call.’”
1785 Heron (Pinkerton)
Heron: v1773
146 the cock crewe] Heron (1785, p. 310): “The supertition of ghosts vanishing at crowing of the cock, is very ancient, as we learn from the Life of Apollonius Tyranæus, by Philostratus, Book IV, ch. 5. where the apparition of Achilles is said to vanish in lightning, ‘for now the crowing of cocks was heard.’”
1793 v1793
Warton note at 411
411 Cock crewe] Warton (apud ed. 1793): “The moment of the evanescence of spirits was supposed to be limited by the crowing of the cock. This belief is mentioned so early as by Prudentius, Cathem. Hymn. [1.5.40]. But some of his commentators prove it to be of much higher antiquity.
“It is a most inimitable circumstance in Shakspeare, so to have managed this popular idea, as to make the Ghost, which has been so long obstinately silent, and of course must be dismissed by the morning, begin or rather prepare to speak, and to be interrupted, at the very critical time of the crowing of the cock.
“Another poet, according to custom, would have suffered his ghost tamely to vanish, without contriving this start, which is like a start of guilt. To say nothing of the aggravation of the future suspence, occasioned by this preparation to speak, and to impart some mysterious secret. Less would have been expected, had nothing been promised. T. Warton.”
1826 sing1
sing1 = Warton, at 411
146 Cock crewe]
1856 sing2
sing2 ≈ Warten without attribution
146 Cock crewe]
sing2
146 Singer (ed. 1856): “It seems that spectres were supposed to maintain an obdurate silence till interrogated by the persons to whom they made their especial appearance. The moment of the evanescence of spirits was supposed to be limited to the crowing of the cock. This belief is very ancient. See Prudentius Cathem. Hym. i.v.40, and the various comments on that passage.”
1912 dtn3
dtn3 = Farmer, in 152
146 the cock]
1931 crg1
crg1: standard
146 cock crewe] Craig (ed. 1931): “According to traditional ghost lore spirits returned to their confines at cock-crow.”
146