HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 3499 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 2951-end ed. Hardin A. Aasand
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
3499 Enter Hamlet and Horatio. 
1869 strat
strat : rowe [notes ROWE’s insertion of scene 2].
1874 Corson
Corson
3499ff Corson (1874, p. 33): <p. 33>“For some reason or other, the 2d Scene of the 5th Act, is less correctly printed in the F. than any other portion of the play.” </p. 33>
1934 Wilson
Wilson
3499ff Wilson (1934, 2:184-85): <p. 184> “In any event, our loss through </p. 184> <p. 185> omission in Q2 is probably considerable. It is certainly so, if 5.2. [3499ff] may be taken as typical, since no fewer than eight directions seem to have been omitted from the Q2 text in this scene. They concern the fencing-match and what ensures therefrom, and may be set out as they appear both in F1 and Q1.
F1 Q1
5.2.277 Prepare to play. Heere they play.
291 They play. They play againe.
292
311 Play. They catch one anothers
313 In scuffling they change Rapiers, and both are
Rapiers. wounded, . . .
333 Hurts the King.
338 King Dyes. The king dies.
342 Dyes. Leartes dies.
“It is of course conceivable that Shakespeare did not trouble to write down every one of these directions in his manuscript; but he cannot have left them all out. And if eight stage-directions are missing in a space of sixty-six lines, how many did the compositor omit in the text as a whole? It is is impossible to tell, for unfortunately the directions in F1 are as little likely to be complete as those in Q2. We have already noted that two are lacking from the first scene in the 1623 text; and it is only too probable that Scribe C ignored many more in the prompt-book he worked from.” </p. 185>
1934 cam3
cam3
3499 Wilson (ed. 1934): “For ‘the hall’ [SD] v. [3638].”
1987 oxf4
oxf4
3499 Hibbard (ed. 1987): “It is marvellously appropriate that the keen and long drawn out duel of wits between the two ‘mighty opposites’, Hamlet and the King, should end in a physical duel between the Prince and the deadliest of the King’s instruments. It is also fitting that this mortal combat, unlike that between old Hamlet and old Fortinbras, which was absolutely fair and conducted according to rules, should take the form of a ‘friendly’ bout masking the deepest treachery and defying every rule of the game.”
1992 fol2
fol2≈ standard
3499 Mowat & Werstine (ed. 1992): “In the hall of the castle, Hamlet tells Horatio how he discovered the king’s plot against him and how he turned the tables on Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. Osric enters to ask, on Claudius’s behalf, that Hamlet fence with Laertes. Hamlet agrees to the contest, despite his misgivings.
“Hamlet is winning the match when Gertrude drinks from the poisoned cup that Claudius has prepared for Hamlet. Laertes then wounds Hamlet with the poisoned rapier. In the scuffle that follows, Hamlet forces an exchange of rapiers, and Hamlet wounds Laertes. As Gertrude dies, Laertes, himself dying, discloses his and Claudius’s plot against Hamlet. Hamlet kills Claudius. Before Hamlet dies, he asks Horatio to tell the full story that has led to these deaths and names Fortinbras heir to the Danish throne. After Hamlet’s death, Fortinbras arrives, claims the crown, and orders a military funeral for Hamlet.”
1993 dent
dent
3499 Andrews (ed. 1989): “This scene returns us to the Castle, where Hamlet is telling Horatio what happened aboard the ship to England.”
3499