HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 3487 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 2951-end ed. Hardin A. Aasand
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
3487 Ham. Heare you sir, 
1870 Miles
Miles
3487-89 Miles (1870, p. 76): <p. 76>“Minds of surpassing reach, hearts of surpassing love, souls of surpassing truth, enjoy a monopoly of the lordly right to acquit others and blame themselves. And when, as in Hamlet’s case, this wide magnanimity is accompanied by refined idealism and morbid delicacy, the smallest approach to violence, however pardonable, is apt to furnish a ground for self-reproach. Even before leaving the grave-yard he attempts a reconciliation,—’[cites 3487-89 ‘Heare . . . euer”]” </p. 76>
1875 Marshall
Marshall
3487-91 Marshall (1875, p. 101): <p. 101>“Hamlet almost justifies this description by the sudden change in his tone from passionate invective to gentle expostulation—[cites 3487-89] Had he been able to restrain himself and to argue calmly with Laertes, he might well have asked him why he execrated the friend of his youth for an act which was committed unintentionally, and which had been bitterly repented, without giving that friend any chance of explaining his conduct. It seems as if Hamlet now felt the effects of reaction after his vehement outburst of rage, and was inclined to yield to that spirit of fatalism which every now and then got possession of him. This is the only explanation which I can see of the somewhat enigmatical words with which he concludes this speech—[cites 3490-91]
“The commentators have not exerted their ingenuity on this passage, which is rather unintelligible: the meaning would seem to be, ‘Not even the strength of Hercules can change the disposition which Nature implants in us; it is not in your nature to understand my motives; and do whatever I will, you will persist in misunderstanding them.’” </p. 101>
1883 wh2
wh2
3487 sir] White (ed. 1883): “This formal courtesy (which Hamlet has not used to Horatio since their first meeting) indicates no change of feeling toward his friend on the Prince’s part, nor any assumption of superior rank, but a slight and momentary hardening of his heart in recollecting what he is about to relate.”
1885 macd
macd
3487 MacDonald (ed. 1885): “Laertes stands eyeing him with evil looks.”
3487