HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 694 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 0-1017 ed. Bernice W. Kliman
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
694 Ghost. I am thy fathers spirit,1.5.9
1770 Gentleman
Gentleman
694-776 I . . . . me] Gentleman (1770, 1:18-19): <p.18>: “The Roman catholic opinion of purgatory is inculcated through the whole of this interview; and funeral rites, or preparatives thereto, particularly mentioned in this line [762], ‘Unhousel’d, unanointed, unaneal’d.’ But whether Shakespeare may thence be deemed a favourer of popish principles, remains a matter of much doubt; and the determination, could we come at it, would be of no consequence to our present purpose; however, let the religious bent be what it may, we must admit the Ghost’s stimulation to revenge, furnishes a very gross idea of immortality, which should be freed from the passions and remembrances of clay; nor does the palliative distinction which forbids any violence against the Queen, take off the imputation of mortal frailty, hanging about an existence merely spiritual; an abrupt departure, and those beautiful lines with which the Ghost disappears, are a very happy conclusion to </p.18><p.19> the scene, which spun out to a greater length would have lost much of its force and beauty.” </p.19>
1773 gent
gent
694-708 I . . . . loue] Gentleman (ed. 1773): “This speech may be styled a most melting, heart-rending sense-alarming address.”
1807 Douce
Douce
694-708 I . . . . loue] Douce (1807, 2:223): “The whole of the ghost’s speech is remarkable for its terrific grandeur.”
1951 Clark
Clark
694-776 Clark (1951, rpt Greenhaven 1999, pp. 104-5) <p. 104> believes that the ghost’s long speeches, “with their invective and moralization are not at all characteristic of the Shakespearean ghosts, who are </p. 104> <p. 105> usually the most reticent of beings. Shakespeare in this part of the play was probably rewriting Kyd.” </p. 105>
694