HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 1718 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 1018-2022 ed. Eric Rasmussen
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
1718 Deuoutly to be wisht to die to sleepe,3.1.63
1733 theo1
theo1: Beaumont & Fletcher
1718 Theobald (ed. 1733): “This admirable fine Reflexion seems, in a paltry Manner, to be sneer’d at by Beaumont and Fletcher in their Scornful Lady. ‘Rog. Have patience, Sir, until our Fellow Nicholas be deceas’d, that is, asleep; to sleep, to dye; to dye, to sleep; a very Figure, Sir.’”
1765 Olivier Goldsmith
Goldsmith
1718-19 to die to sleepe No more] Goldsmith (1765, apud Williamson p. 12) The phrase “contains an ambiguity, which all the art of punctuation cannot remove; for it may signify that ’to die’ is to sleep no more: or the expression ’no more’ may be considered as an abrupt apostrophe in thinking, as if he meant to say ’no more of this reflection.’ ”
1773 v1773
v1773
1718 Steevens (ed. 1773): “This passage is ridiculed in the Scornful Lady of B. and Fletcher, as follows. ‘—be deceas’d, that is asleep, for so the word is taken. To sleep, to die; to die, to sleep; a very figure, Sir.’”
-1845 mhun1
mhun1
1717-18 tis...wisht] Hunter (-1845, f. 226v): “[Greek text]— Herodotus. [Polyhym?] The resemblance is only casual & the sentiment not peculiar.”
1869 hall
hall
1718 Hall (1869, pp. 11-12): “Necessity, thou mother of all, is the governing power, and the conclusion arrived at, is that of non-futurity. Not only does this speech show that the thoughts of Hamlet are sceptical, but it also shows </p. 11><p. 12>that he wishes for no future state of existence; he would that the old Sadducean doctrine were true. [Quotes TLN 1714-18] The same idea Shakspere hath pourtrayed in his play of the Tempest, when Prospero exclaims ‘Our little life is rounded with a sleep’ A. IV. s.1.”
1909 rushtonn
rushtonn
1718-19 to sleepe, To sleepe] Rushton (1909, pp. 107): “In these passages Shakespeare, with the word with which he finishes a verse, begins the next, and Puttenham says— ‘Ye have another sort of repetition, when wiith the word by which you finish your verse, ye begin the next verse with the same, as thus— “Comfort it for man to have a wife, Wife chaste, and wise, and lowly all her life.” Or thus— “Your beauty was the cause of my first love; Love while I live, that I may sore repent.”
‘The Greeks call the figure Anadiplosis, I call him the Redouble as the original bears.’”
1718