HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 771 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 0-1017 ed. Bernice W. Kliman
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
771 Against thy mother ought, leaue her to heauen,1.5.86
1879 Blackwell’s
Anon.
771 leaue her to heauen] Anon. (1879, pp. 466-7) <p. 466> Hamlet "tries to rouse himself, but in vain. What were the good? If Claudius were slain, would that restore honour and purity to the desecrated house? could anything remake that polluted mother into the type of holy womanhood above corruption?" </p. 466>
<p. 467> "As Macbeth murdered sleep, so has villany murdered truth, the soul of the world; but that last and awful murder is not to be made up for by the death of the villain. That is trivial, a nothing, a momentary anodyne, a little salve put to the burning of the heart-deep wound: but no remedy; for remedy is beyond possibility, beyond even hope." </p. 467>
Ed. note: This is as good an explanation as any for the paradox of the two-fold task laid upon Hamlet: to avenge a murder but to leave his mother to heaven; how can he do that if her sin [in his eyes] is greater than all?
1924 vand
vand contra Greg, Wilson
771 Van Dam (1924, pp. 55-6) <p. 55> thinks that there is no sign that the queen is guilty of murder in Q2. “In real life things may be hidden behind what we hear and see but not in a work of art; what a poet does not tell us or intimate to us in a drama, he cannot wish to exist for us.” Her guilt is incest, which he calls one of the seven deadly sins. Q1’s express denial of her guilt makes the play clearer for a play-going public but changes nothing. Van Dam also denies that she was an adulterous: “we are told nothing of the kind [. . . ] ” </p. 55> <p. 56> “Claudius, by persuading Gertrard to marry him, seduced her to shameful lust and incest [. . . ] .” The word adulterate means unchaste rather than modern adultery. </p.56>
1980 pen2
pen2
771 leaue . . . heauen] Spencer (ed. 1980): “entrust her to God’s judgement. According to usual religious teaching, revenge upon Claudius should also be left to heaven.”
2006 ard3q2
ard3q2: xref
771 ought] Thompson & Taylor (ed. 2006): “anything (as at [875])”

ard3q2
771 leaue . . . heauen] Thompson & Taylor (ed. 2006): “i.e. let God judge and punish her. Again, the Ghost seems to assume that she is not equally guilty.”
2007 ShSt
Stegner
771-3 leaue her . . . sting her] Stegner (2007, p. 113): The “Ghost intimates that a transformation of confession has occurred when he commands Hamlet to ’[l]eave [Gertrude] to heaven, And to those thorns that in her bosom lodge To prick and sting her’ ”
Ed. note: Perhaps contrition, the first step toward confession, is what the ghost thinks she has reached.
771 772 773