HW HomePrevious CNView CNView TNMView TNINext CN

Line 308 - Commentary Note (CN) More Information

Notes for lines 0-1017 ed. Bernice W. Kliman
For explanation of sigla, such as jen, see the editions bib.
308 No iocond health that Denmarke drinkes to day,1.2.125
61 308 310 363 612 613 621+1 951 1110 2173 3731 3736 3739 3748
1762 Dodd
Dodd
308-11 Dodd (1752, 2:257-8), <p. 257> writing about 3736-9, points out that “There is in the beginning of the play a passage like this: [quotes 308-11]. </p. 257> <p. 258> Shakespear keeps up the characters of the people where his scene lies, and therefore dwells much on the Danish drinking: [quotes 612-16]. A custom, as Hamlet observes in the subsequent lines, greatly to the discredit of their nation, and more honour’d in the breach than the observance.” </p. 258>
1765 john1
john1 ≈ Dodd without attribution
308 Denmarke drinkes] Johnson (ed. 1765): “The King’s intemperance is very strongly impressed; every thing that happens to him gives him occasion to drink.”
Ed. note: Johnson knew Dodd and tried, unsuccesfully, to prevent his being hanged.
1773 v1773
v1773 = john1
308 Denmarke drinkes]
ck v1778 v1785 etc.
Ed. note: Though Johnson’s observation may be an exaggeration, certainly drinking is impressed in the first and last acts, which may be sufficient to create the impression.
1784 Davies
Davies: v1773
308-9 Denmarke drinkes] Davies (1784, 3:11): “I cannot think, with Dr. Johnson, that these lines particularly mark the King’s fondness for drinking. Drunkenness was the national vice, as Hamlet himself afterwards confesses.
“This seems to have been pointed out, by the author, as the King’s first appearance in public after his usurping the crown and marrying his sister; and is therefore celebrated as a gala-day. He therefore seizes an opportunity to compliment Hamlet’s concession, as he would fain term it, in his own favour, by firing off the cannon to his honour at every toast.”
1807 Douce
Douce
308 Denmarke drinkes] Douce (1807, 2:219-20): <p. 219> “A lively French traveller being asked what he had seen in Denmark, replied; ‘rien de singulier, sinon qu’on y chante tous les jours, le roy boit;’ alluding to the French mode of celebrating Twelfth-day. See De Brieux, Origines de quelques coutûmes, p. 56. Heywood in his Philocothonista, or The drunkard opened, dissected, and anatomized, 1635, 4to, speaking of what he calls the vinosity of nations, says of </p.219> <p.220> the Danes, that ‘they have made a profession thereof from antiquity, and are the first upon record that brought their wassel-bowls and elbowe-deep healthes into this land.’” </p. 220>
ck v1803
1813 v1813
v1813= v1793
308 Denmarke drinkes]
1819 cald1
cald1: Douce +
308 Denmarke drinkes] Caldecott (ed. 1819): “ ‘The priest, in like manner, is to be excused, who, having taken his preparatives over evening, when all men cry ( as the manner is) The king drinketh, chanting his masse the next morning, fell asleep in his memento; and when he awoke, added, with a loude voice, The king drinketh.’ —R. C.’s H. Stephens’s Apology for Herodotus, fo. 1608. p. 189. ”
Ed note: At 612, Caldecott has a long note.
ck v1821another quotation, a translation of DOUCE’s quotation it seems, from Apology for Herodotus but what I don’t know yet is if he had this from someone else in another spot—there are so many opportunities to remark on drink and drinking.
1913 Trench
Trench
308-11 Trench (1913, p. 53): “Such delight on the King’s part over what he takes to mean that Hamlet is going to be fairly amenable looks like evidence of great uneasiness, as though there had been upon his mind some burden not unconnected with Hamlet. So with magnificent condescension he actually says to him ’Be as ourself in Denmark’ [305]. Thus the King, happy in the thought of the success achieved by his diplomacy, ’smiles and smiles’ [793] upon Hamlet . . . .”
1939 kit2
kit2: standard
308 Denmarke] Kittredge (ed. 1939): "Cf. [cn 61]."
1953 Joseph
Joseph
308-11 No iocond health . . . thunder] Joseph (1953, p. 52): “For Claudius, this is the moment of greatest triumph: in his appearance, in the attitude of others towards him, there is no suggestion that he is anything but an ideal king, with all the superb qualities which that implies. . . . And yet as he wrote the play, Shakespeare . . . had also imagined him guilty at this very moment of two horrid, ugly crimes.” Ed. note: Joseph ignores the fact of performance, where many other impressions are possible.
1982 ard2
ard2: standard
308 Denmarke] Jenkins (ed. 1982): “the King of Denmark. Cf. [61].”

ard2 = john + xrefs
308 drinkes] (ed. 1982): “The King’s intemperance is very strongly impressed; everything that happens to him gives occasion to drink’ (Johnson). Cf. [363, 612-21, 1110, 2173, 2364, 3727 ff.], and, for an appropriate nemesis, [3807-9].”
1985 cam4
cam4
308 Denmarke] Edwards (ed. 1985): "Once again, the king is meant."
1987 oxf4
oxf4
308-11 No . . . thunder] Hibbard (ed. 1987): "Wilson aptly quotes the following passage from Stow’s Annals (p. 1433), describing the events that accompanied a royal christening and the presentation of the order of the Garter to Christian IV of Denmark in the summer of 1603: ‘That afternoon the King went aboard the English ship [lying off Elsinore] and had a banquet prepared for him upon the upper decks, which were hung with an awning of tissue; every health reported [led to the firing ring of] six, eight, or ten shot of great ordnance, so that during the King’s abode, the ship discharged 160 shot.’ "
1988 bev2
bev2
308 iocond] Bevington (ed. 1988): “merry.”
1992 fol2
fol2bev2 without attribution
308 iocund health] Mowat & Werstine (ed. 1992): “merry toast”
2006 ard3q2
ard3q2: john
308-11 No . . . thunder] Thompson & Taylor (ed. 2006): “’The king’s intemperance is very strongly impressed; everything that happens to him gives him occasion to drink’ (Johnson).”

ard3q2: standard
308 iocond] Thompson & Taylor (ed. 2006): “joyful”